Debate Tomenable's division of Europe

[Tomenable]

Switzerland - despite its lack of Slavic influence - was added to the Central group because it fits it better than the Latin-Celtic group; and Sweden - despite having perhaps more of Eastern European admixture than of Celtic admixture - was added to the NW group because Eastern influences there are not strong enough to warrant its belonging to the NE group:

LINK to Map

Latin-Celtic can also be called Romance-Celtic.

Feel free to comment, debate and discuss!

 

[Tomenable]

In France DF27 & U152 are more common than Z290 & U106, one of reasons why I added France to the Latin-Celtic group:

 

[Vallicanus]

In France DF27 & U152 are more common than Z290 & U106, one of reasons why I added France to the Latin-Celtic group:

Are you sure Italy as a whole has 51pc U-152. Maybe in the north and centre but it must be much lower in the South.

 

[Tomenable]

Are you sure Italy as a whole has 51pc U-152. Maybe in the north and centre but it must be much lower in the South.

It is 51% of all R1b, not 51% of all Y chromosomes.

 

[Tomenable]

Here is a European PCA which I made based on my regional averages for European countries in Eurogenes K36 calculator:

I coloured countries in this PCA based on divisions of Europe into 5 regions from my map in the opening post of this thread:

LINK

 

[Tomenable]

For Switzerland I did not include a Swiss Italian sample in the PCA.

If I included it there would be one Swiss dot within the Italian cluster.

And for Russia I included only ethnic Russians in the PCA, no minorities.