Search results

E-V13 branches like Berisha-Sopi, which are founder effects with relatively shallow tmrcas like 850YBP (in contrast to deeper clades like the E-BY4465 you mentioned) are misused in the arguments for "diversity" because they are taken out of their proper context. We can imagine an equivalent...

A. R1b-Z2103 appears in ancient Thrace, Macedonia, and ancient Moesia/Dacia (Serbia), and being the original Yamnaya lineage which we know was spread all over the balkans, it should be expected to have descendant branches all over the balkans, so it cannot pre-emptively be claimed as a western...

This is an irrelevant deflection considering Rrenjet is still publicly declaring in 2025 that R1b-Z2705 migrated to Albania in the Roman era. This necessarily means R1b-Z2705 was not in Albania before the Romans, i.e. it wasn't in Illyria and part of the Illyrian ethnogenesis. This is...

We already know that z2705 must have reached Albania in the roman period so pointing to the roman period is a deflection. What is relevant is where this was during the Glasinac-Mati period i.e. during the Illyrian ethnogenesis, and for now the evidence of R1b-BY611 seems to point to it being...

Exactly, if we dig deeper it is more obvious, for example: in tosks its even less, the total perecentage of slavic paternal lineages in tosks is more than twice that of j2b-l283. That is why it is so important for them to forcefully couple J2b-L283 + R1b-z2705 to pump the absolute numbers up...

Another problem is the way they are pre-emptively framing Albanian Z2705 and Ev13 branches showing up outside of Illyria as only being possible by vlach mediation, like in that arbanology article that theone shared above. https://arbanology.substack.com/p/e-by4465-a-look-into-a-proto-albanian...

1. "a spread from the Pannonian Basin between the European Alps and the Carpathians" This area is not the "western-central balkans". This region is also not within the territories of the Glasinac-Mati culture that was the Illyrian culture. This means that the ancestor of the Albanians who are...

R1b-Z2705 was most probably not an Glasinac-Mati lineage (and therefore not Illyrian) going by what we know so far though. So R1b-Z2705 is an argument against Illyrian origin for the Albanian language. Rrenjet themselves have written about this: https://rrenjet.com/r-cts9219/#R-BY611 So...

Saw this claim here that Nietzsche was E-V13: https://goto.now/uCl7J

As far as i have read from the main classical sources that cover the subject, there are no ancient references describing the Dardanians taking part in the so called Illyrian revolt, which was in truth mainly a delmato-pannonian revolt that also bled into Illyria. That map is the work of a...

I agree that its a leap forward. There are still some issues there that we understand, but credit to them for at least pushing some things forward. I'm sure a lot of the usual suspects will be seething right now.

The Albanian Genetics project Rrënjët updated their page about E-V13. Here are their claims, googls translated for non-Albanian speakers: Possible area of spread 4000-5000 years ago, according to today's results Ancient E-V13 results: >2500 years – red; 2000-2500 years – orange...

Very very interesting, i guess these are more or less the same people that lazic calls the "dented ware" people. Its hard to know because i only have access to minimal papers through google translate.

Here for example bruzmi/corrigendum/hasangjekaj let the mask slip. Even some of his more die hard baboon followers will do a double take here and start to get an uneasy feeling in their stomach, as his narrative of EEF slave E-V13s assimilated by the Illyrian J2b-L283s comes out in the open...

Well, there are thankfully non-Albanian E-V13s that serve as checks and balances in this regard. They have skin in the game and are curious about E-V13's origin but have no investment in the Albanian continuity melodrama. My predictions for the spin and obfuscations...

I understand the sentiment, but don't agree ultimately. There are enough diaspora albanians alone that have been educated outside of this context. Likewise the internet itself will do enough, as more and more people test on their own and ask questions. Just like you see some random old american...

The funniest thing here is how all these new results are not shared by Rrenjtlet but are also being supressed by their circle of morons such as "Arbanology" who have shared nothing of these new results to his audience (i.e. about the oldest e-v13 sample yet found in Thracian Hallstatt and so...

If you're referring to me with this comment on "dormant" then you should know that I deactivated Albhistory a month ago before this paper ever came out. You are as wrong as you always were. Anyway, as of a couple of days ago Albhistory is now also permanently deleted. If I could I would also...

Classical sources where the Dardani are referred to as either Illyrians, Thracian, Trojan, or as just themselves, i.e. Independent. We have considerably more sources calling them something distinct from Illyrian

Hundreds of samples from the steppe and not a single J2b-L283 yet. No evidence this was a steppe halplo