Search results

Can you re-post your attachments. I cannot see them. A minority of R-Z280 could indeed be germanic. Perhaps I am mistaken but I think that a R-Z280 ancient sample (dated around 1000 BC) was found in central Germany. If you look at the country report for FGC10360 on FTDNA, 4.65 % of the carriers...

Could you explain the relation between Y18331 and Bastarnae ?

It says there was a substantial Ancestry shift towards Eastern Mediterranean / Near East. In the S2 table, I could find : > R-F1345 (under Z93>Z94>Z2124>Z2122). > R-M207 (but it seems it is R2a); But neither the article nor the Supp. Materials say anything specific about R1a and how it...

R1a-CTS1211-CTS8816-Y2902 - YP3994 I saw in the recent paper « Ancient Rome : A genetic crossroad... » that Haplogroup R1a (+J1 & E1b) was present in Rome and/or its surroundings during the Imperial period 27-300 BCE (see Supp. Materials, p. 12) and Figure S5. It is not found anymore in Late...

What I understand is that certain lineages of said culture became germanic (through assimilation) while others finished their ongoing ethnogenesis process and became slavic. Would it be right to call it a Proto-Slavic culture then ?

About language and culture, which belong to the main elements of an ethnos.

Would it help to upload the data to Yfull ? The Sicilian could be arberesh. I found someone with the same family name leading some arberesh fighters during the Italian revolution.

How to do this comparison ?

I just received my BigY results. I have 18 private variants. And I cluster with the Sicilian (he is my only BigY match and we share one variant). But it does not say anything about the TMRCA. How can I calculate it ?

Thanks for your answer and the link. While certain R1a subclades present in the Balkans may have been brought by Dacian/Gothic tribes, I do not think that this works for most R1a in the Balkans and for R-CTS8816 as whole. Distribution and high frequencies concentrated in Slavic countries speak...

The Goths might have brought (among others) in Spain, Southern France and Italy R1a-M558>CTS8816 (under Z280) but this is based on the modern distribution of this subclade (and, to my knowledge, still needs to be confirmed by ancient DNA). Do you know whether CTS8816 and/or its subclades...

I also noticed that the YDNA path to R-YP3994 has been updated on SNP tracker. Of course, it is not really reliable since this simulated route is only calculated based on the geographical origins reported by the modern carriers (and not on ancient DNA) but it is funny to see that, after...

R1a-CTS1211 > CTS8816 > Y2902 > YP3994 in Albania and in the Balkans I just noticed on www.yfull.com/tree (v. 7.08) that the subclades under R-CTS8816/Y2902 have been reorganized. As a result, R-YP3994 does not appear as basal to Y2902 anymore but in the end of the list. Has anyone an...

Indeed. And in my humble opinion it is meaningless to mention R1a in general without specifying which subclades would be dorian related. By the way, it is not the first time I read such unsubstatiated assertions about ancient Greek, Macedonian and/or Dorian R1a but no serious source or...

"Regarding Sardinians, the overwhelming majority of their results on YFull come from this study. As you can see, 1200 samples were tested with high coverage tests, so they are over-represented right now. As a consequence, you can see scattered Sardinian results almost on every branch." I...

Doubtful. The map is pretty old. I agree. The map surprised me and it is why I asked whether there was some scientific/archeological ground to support it. The map could be old indeed. But If you look at "Haplogroup R1a" history (last update in 2018), there is also a chapter named "The greek...

I found this surprising map on this site : Is there is any scientific/archeologic evidence of the Ancient Greeks and Macedonians (2000/1500 BC) being R1a tribes originating from Trzciniec Culture ?

Indeed, I found a basal R-L1029 on yfull. And according to Jordanès, there has been some interaction between the Goths and the Vandals (the former having subdued the latter upon their arrival in the Vistula bassin during the first century CE). But Sardinian R1a seems quite diverse, as I also...

I do not know for sure but the reasons can be multiple (genetic drift, bottlenecks, more or less succesful expansions after the 7th century). Besides, we also have to take into account that the original genetic make up of said tribes was not identical (which is also reflected by the frequencies...

Here is a link to a recent scientific paper (Stolarek, 2019) describing the Goths' initial migration and its impact on the MtDNA of central-east Europe. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-43183-w The authors describe these migrations as follows: A. In the first stage, the Goths...